The Best Bay Rum Shaving Soap Guide

The Best Bay Rum Shaving Soap Guide

By Kings of Today | Updated Oct 09, 2019

best bay rum shaving soap

The best bay rum shaving soap creates a luxurious lather that can easily soften your beard and make your razor glide, which results in a more enjoyable shave.

While shaving soaps may have higher initial costs than shaving creams, the shaving soaps often last longer than shaving creams and can often be replaced with refills once they run out.

Best Bay Rum Shaving Soap Quick Review

Product Best For Our Rating
1. Gilbert Henry Shaving Soap Smooth Shave
2. Col Conk Shaving Soap Gift Giving
3. Dr. Jon's Natural Shaving Soap Traveling
4. Captain's Choice Shaving Soap Sensitive Skin
5. Barberry Coast Shave Soap All Skin Types

Top Choice: Gilbert Henry Shaving Soap

With essential oils to keep the skin hydrated and a classic bay rum fragrance, this shave soap is here to stay in the world of men’s grooming.

1. Gilbert Henry Shaving Soap
Best For

Smooth Shave

Our Rating
2. Col Conk Shaving Soap
Best For

Gift Giving

Our Rating
3. Dr. Jon's Natural Shaving Soap
Best For


Our Rating
4. Captain's Choice Shaving Soap
Best For

Sensitive Skin

Our Rating
5. Barberry Coast Shave Soap
Best For

All Skin Types

Our Rating

Why Use Shaving Soap?

Shaving soap offers many benefits from modern shaving gels and foams. First and foremost, shaving soaps help to soften the beard, allowing your razor to do its best work.

The result is a close and comfortable shave. In addition, shaving soaps create a slick surface for your razor to glide over. They are also available in a wide range of scents to cater to the varied tastes of users.

Lastly, shaving soaps last much longer than shaving creams and gels, which makes them a better bang for your buck, especially in the long term.

Choosing the Right Shaving Soap for You

Shaving soaps are available in various forms; they may come in a bowl or on their own as refills. There are two main types of bowls for shaving soaps: plastic and wooden.

The shape and size of shaving soaps is mainly determined by the brand. This means that refills for one brand may not fit the shaving bowls of another brand.

Shaving soaps in wooden bowls are the most popular mainly because they look great in any bathroom. They are often given out as gifts, with or without shaving brushes.

On the other hand, shaving soap refills are suitable for those who already have soap bowls and all they need is a new shaving soap.

If you are traveling and need a shaving soap, consider getting a shaving soap stick. They are great for travelers because they are small and have watertight lids. They are usually applied directly to the face, after which you use a shaving brush to whip up some lather.

best bay rum shaving soap

Preparing Your Face and Beard for Shaving

To achieve a close and comfortable shave, it is important to properly prepare your face and beard for shaving. One of the most common causes of post-shave irritation is poor preparation. You can achieve great shave results by taking just a few minutes to get ready for shaving.

Hot Water

One of the most essential requirements for shaving is hot water because it helps to soften the beard and makes it easier for your razor to cut the beard. In addition, it helps to clean dirt and dead skin that has built up around the beard hairs.

You can apply the hot water on your face in various ways: You may shave immediately after a hot shower, apply a towel soaked in hot water on your beard for a minute or two, or simply splash some hot water on your face for a few minutes.

Pre Shave Balms and Lotions

These are usually recommended for softening tough beards to minimize irritation and razor bumps. Pre shave balms and lotions are normally applied to the beard area and then left for a few minutes to soften the beard.

While they do their work, you may do something else like brushing your teeth or whipping up some shaving lather. Thereafter, you may rinse off the pre shaving balms or simply apply the lather directly over the top.

Pre Shave Oils

These are normally applied before the shaving lather. The main function of pre shaving oil is to provide additional lubrication so that your razor can easily glide across your beard during shaving.

New Wet Shavers

There is nothing like over preparing for a shave. New wet shavers are advised to pay as much attention as possible to preparation to ensure the best shave. Once you get great shaves with minimal or no preparation, you can now reduce the amount of time you spend on preparation, if you feel the need to.

Post Shave Care

Your skin is left vulnerable and exposed after shaving, which is why it is important to treat it properly to minimize irritation and enhance comfort. First, rinse your face with warm water to rid the skin of all lather.

Once your skin is clean, rinse your face again, but use cold water this time around. Cold water helps to calm the skin and open the pores to prevent trapping of oils, which may cause breakouts.

If you decide to use your towel to dry your face, simply dab it on your face instead of rubbing your face with the towel. This will help minimize irritation.

If you have spots that are bleeding due to cuts and nicks experienced during shaving, block them with alum blocks or apply styptic pencil to the spots.

Alternatively, use an alum block over the entire area that has been shaved, as alum blocks have great antiseptic properties. If you decide to apply an alum block all over the shaved area, leave it for a few minutes to dry before rinsing with cold water.

Aftershave Splash

This is a liquid that is often alcohol based and has antiseptic, toner and astringent properties to help calm the skin after shaving. Aftershave splashes are usually scented and recommended for shaving in warmer climates.

Aftershave Balms

Unlike aftershave splashes, aftershave balms have thicker consistency and are often used for their moisturizing properties that offer great relief after shaving. They are recommended for use in colder climates.

There are many bay rum shave soaps on the market, which may make it difficult for you to separate the good from the bad from the average. Therefore, we have researched the best bay rum shave soaps on the market and recommend the following products.

Best Bay Rum Shaving Soap Review

1. Gilbert Henry Shaving Soap

best bay rum shaving soap best bay rum shaving soap

With essential oils to keep the skin hydrated and a classic bay rum fragrance, this shave soap is here to stay in the world of men’s grooming.

This bay rum shave soap whips up exceptional lather to prevent post shave rashes and burns. With glycerin and lanolin, this shave soap will help you get that protected and moisturizing shave.

The best part, you get to enjoy its inviting and warm bay rum scent throughout your shave. The scent is a blend of cinnamon, blackstrap rum, orange and a hint of vanilla. Like a breeze from the ocean, this scent will leave you feeling refreshed and cool.

  • Provides comfortable shave
  • Authentic bay rum scent
  • Great value for money
  • Long lasting, consistent lather
  • Costly

2. Col Conk Shaving Soap

best bay rum shaving soap best bay rum shaving soap

This shave soap has a scent that never goes out of style. As you may imagine, the scent is a bit tropical but not frivolous.

This shaving soap smells high quality and it really is a great stuff. It contains glycerin and avocado oil, which provide excellent lubrication and hydration.

This soap lathers up well and has a rich aroma that does not smell cheap. In addition, it is small enough to fit your standard shave soap bowl. It contains natural ingredients and is free of sulfates or parabens. It is totally safe to use on your face and will provide the ultimate protection from razor nicks and bumps.

  • Great lather
  • Fantastic bay rum scent
  • Hydrating and moisturizing
  • Natural ingredients
  • None

3. Captain's Choice Shaving Soap

best bay rum shaving soap best bay rum shaving soap

Scented with the brand’s popular bay rum, this shave soap is rich, luxurious and provides lasting lather.

This product was introduced after extensive testing. Its bespoke scent leaves many wet shavers rejoicing. It comes in a large bowl suitable for lathering. This shaving soap contains vegetable glycerin and coconut oil, essential components for producing voluminous lather.

It produces rich and creamy lather that lasts for long and will give you the glide you want for that close shave. However, its biggest selling point is its fragrance. The fragrance is luxurious and does not overwhelm the senses.

  • Thick and rich lather
  • Delightful bay rum scent
  • Hydrating properties
  • Oversized tub

4. Barberry Coast Shave Soap

best bay rum shaving soap best bay rum shaving soap

This shave soap features the same old classic bay rum fragrance that is exceptional and wonderfully crafted.

This shave soap has succeeded admiringly in providing fantastic lather, amazing scent and great value. It does not skimp on hydrating and nourishing ingredients all to ensure that you get a great shave and great value for your money.

It contains glycerin, lanolin, almond oil, Shea butter and coconut oil, all of which contribute to its rich and creamy lather. Whether you are new or experienced shaver, you cannot escape its classic bay rum aroma. Its scent is a blend of orange, cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves.

  • Natural ingredients
  • Moisturizing properties
  • Free of synthetic chemicals
  • Lathers well
  • A bit pricey

5. Dr. Jon's Natural Shaving Soap

best bay rum shaving soap best bay rum shaving soap

Loaded with moisturizing and hydrating oils and scented with bay rum, this shave soap has fully embraced the bay rum movement.

This is quality shaving soap that will easily generate a thick, creamy lather that will cushion your face against nicks and burns. In addition, it is loaded with conditioning oils to help keep your face looking healthy and moisturized.

This shave soap takes lather to a whole new level. It is a masculine classic with a blend of bay rum essential oils, dark tea and a twist of lime.

  • Amazing bay rum fragrance
  • Protects from razor nicks and burns
  • All natural ingredients
  • Recyclable packaging
  • Requires more water to lather

So Which is the Best Bay Rum Shaving Soap

The market is flooded with many bay rum soaps, with some claiming to be the best bay rum shaving soap on the market. The brand you decide to choose is entirely determined by your preference.

However, if we had to choose the best bay rum shave soap on the market, it would be the Gilbert Henry Shaving Soap. This soap provides great lather that lasts for as long as you shave. In addition, it has a rich and luxurious bay rum scent that is not too overpowering and rather enjoyable.

Based on 23 Users

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *